And this is in all seriousness. I hope that this honest analysis will also help Doppleganger further better the game as well as this post will help bring in some new users via search engines
.
You don't have to read all of this if you don't want, I just wanted to voice my opinion.
I've always found myself searching for virtual worlds to be apart of. The first virtual world I've ever been on wayyyy back when was The Palace.
It may look like a big window of crap right now, but back then that was the most awesome place to chat! Age group of 12-19 maybe, with avatars and clothes that you could draw and create yourself with your paint program and import into the game for you to wear, and for anyone to pick up if you choose to drop it.

What made the palace so fun was the ease of customization and complete control of the user to make the community their own.When you talk, a chat bubble comes from your head, along with a separate chat box as well showing all of what was said in the entire chat room.
Another thing that made this Chat interesting was The Palace - Server. You could create your own chat server with your own chat rooms, backgrounds, and even have some rooms locked. As long as you kept your server program running, anyone could come to your virtual world. Some people ran hotels where you could have your own actual room that was password protected, with furniture images you could import, and stuff like that. And this was such a simple thing that even me at the time, a 12 year old, could set one up. You could even your own music to play when you enter in certain rooms.
So what makes this chat client good?
Community control to make their own worlds
Community control to create their own looks and clothes
Community even created their own events like model competitions, family's w/ doll house backgrounds, salons, clubs, resturaunts, etc...

on the Palace server, any image could be used as your background settings
Attractive avatars. I could find a good example of the chat screenshot, but those avatar dolls are mostly what everyone used.
Everything was free because it was all user created. Everyone shared avatars and clothes if they wanted.
What made it sucky?
Well at the time, nothing. Technology was so behind back then, I was actually playing that on dial-up. But it most certainly wasn't in 3D, and at the time I didn't' expect any chat program to be that advanced so The Palace chat was a very addicting place to be and was actually pretty safe.
And this is the direction I hope that vSide is going towards
Now that virtual chats have evolved into the 3D worlds and have gotten more "real", of course not all of these attributes that The Palace had can be added, because these people need to make money. But have some of these Virtual World creators forgotten that it is the community that REALLY creates the world, and not so much the creators?
Before I got into an actual 3D world, I played on a 3D pixelized world called Habbo Hotel. You've all probably heard of it. That's when I was introduced to the whole fake currency thing. I thought it absurd to have to pay for graphic images to only be represented in a virtual world.
But what made this such an big leap from The Palace was the interactivity between User and Program.
You could go to a restaurant's in Habbo Hotel, tell the person at the counter you want a burger, and a burger would appear in your hand a few moments later! Now THAT was neat. Unlike The Palace where by you'd probably just draw a burger and tell your avatar to wear it.
On Habbo hotel is also where I was introduced to the whole "Apartment" thing. You could choose your apartment layout, walls, floors, but wait a minute... i have no furniture! Of course they start you off with a few points to get some, but there is no way you can gain your own points with out buying some T.T
Well that sux. No way to express creativity with out a CC. My parents would have never given me money to put towards a game. So I got bored with that quickly.
Pros of Habbo Hotel:
Resturaunt things were cool how you can order food
Pool area/diving board where you can perforom tricks and receive ratings
Can have your own place
Community hosted events like falling furni
Cons of Habbo Hotel:
Avatar limitation... looked like legos
No real way to earn points
Graphics were okay, but nothing to special... definitely a step down from the Palace because the creators controlled the look.
So after habbo hotel, of course imitations followed, like coke music.
Now THAT was fun because you could actually earn points by buying their virtual soda and looking under the virtual cap...
Okay so fast forward away from that stuff and onto the REAL 3D stuff. I've tried just about... hmm ALL of them.
Mooove Online
UH... need I say more? This sucked big time. But at least you started off with your own virtual partment with fabric, ceilings, and floors you could import yourself. That meaning any image you can find you could put on your walls, you could even hang pictures of yourself in these rooms too.
So what turned me off about this chat? Well, the age group were well in their 30's and 40's for one, graphics were crap, movements/animations were crap, it's like Second Life on steroids.
Active Worlds

A bigger pile of crap with ishtier graphics. I couldn't understand how to use it, the age group was probably wayy older than I was. And it just didn't please me at all. I'm pretty sure both this and Moove Online had a currency thing too, but I never went too deep into the game to find out.
Fast Forward to the pretty looking stuff.
IMVU

Okay, now when I crash landed on IMVU I really liked what I saw. The graphics were cartoony, yet 3D, fairly attractive and could be user created. The currency system works as follows:
You can either buy IMVU credits, or earn them by selling clothes, furniture, animations, etc at your store, winning the jackpot, or by doing basic chat.
What I loved about IMVU was that no two people would ever look alike because there are just SOOO much stuff you can buy to customize yourself. Literally thousands upon thousands to buy.
But uh... wait a minute.. why am I glued to this effin chair. Yea... IMVU is strictly instant messenger and not a walk around chat. Well that sucks doesn't it. You can only move as far as your furniture goes, and can only do special actions where there are special spots or furniture enabling you to do so. Well that sux.
Pros:
Community created avatars, clothes, furnitures, scenes
Community created events
Community created actions
No-two avatars look alike (unless you really want them too)
Good currency system, you can buy and sell credits as you wish and make a profit
Animated Interaction with other avatars
Cons:
Not a walk around chat
Limited to scenes, furnitures, actions based upon what you can afford
Not really virtual worlds, just virtual settings.
Before I hit IMVU, i actually touched on There.com

Now I have to admit, when I first downloaded There.com I thought my search was over. This chat world had everything.
Pros:
MANY Games to play with your vFriends
Hoverboards, buggies, Hoverboats, paint ball guns, card games....
Dancing introduced
You can have a pet
You can easily interact with other avatars in a sychronized manner. (hugs, kissing, hi 5's)
The radio plays in certain places
Voice chat (the avatars mouth moves and synchs to what is being said)
Cons:
Currency system is bleh....no real way to earn points unless by attending events and if someone chooses to award you points having done so.
Graphics are okay... but a bit blocky
Your avatar gets ugly noobish clothes unless you have money to buy new ones
You can't use Voice chat unless you buy premium membership for 10 dollars.
You can't afford a home unless your rich
I'm not going to touch on VMTV because they use the same software as There.com
Second Life

We've ALL heard of THIS game.
I mean cmon, you can have sex, have a pet, own a house, furnish it, run your own stores, quit your real day job, and earn money on your fake one, drive cars, get married, fly, and did I mention theres sex? So why does it suck?
Well a game like this appeals only to certain age group. You know... 30-60 something year olds who are actually REALLY sick of their first lives. Bad marriages, stressful jobs. A place where they can get away and be who ever they wanna be. But not everyone has the money these adults do to have a "second life" and that's what makes it difficult.
Pros:
All of those listed above
Community created avatars I think....
Community created... Community, buildings, stores, clubs, restaurants, you name it
I THINK you can earn money by working for someone at a store or something and can convert Linden Dollars to real dollars
To be quite honest, it's one of the main reasons Second Life gets so much attention is because like The Palace, the Community creates the world.
Cons:
Age group, not suited for those of a much younger age
Graphics are absolute bullocks as well as actions
I THINK you can earn money by working for someone
I'm going to pause for a second and make not of something about the evolution of virtual worlds from this point on. I always knew that the next step to virtual worlds was the streaming aspect WAY before Kaneva popped out. Being able to play videos from a 3D TV, and music from a 3D stereo, and hang real pictures from a 3D frame. That is what makes Kaneva intersting, but it doesn't neccesarily make Kaneva good.
Kaneva
Pros:
Community controlled media
Customizable apartments, uploadable pictures into apartments as well as uploadable carpets, walls, textures.
Cons:
Graphics are horrid
Places are empty
Not much to do
Not many actions
I THINK the only way to get money is to buy it
Okay So I'm not going to be bias kiss-ass in this post and say that vSide is the best virtual world, because that wouldn't necessarily be true. But vSide is still a work in progress that has GREAT potential to be. There are many things that vSide still lacks, yet there are many things that vSide has that gives them advantage over other virtual worlds.
Pros:
Avatars are attractive, and yes that matters. Figures are realistic as well as the actions and dances they perform
Community created/hosted events
Currency system, you're able to gain points by being active in the world and doing trivia
Music environment wherever you go
Customizable affordable apartments with streaming media
Shopping experience is in the virtual world rather than in a browser
Cons:
Horrible lag in congregated areas
Everyone looks
similar
Creator controlled world
Not much to do besides party and host parties
No avatar-to-avatar animated interaction
So why am I saying all of this if vSide isn't the best?
Because I know that vSide is still in beta giving them the opportunity to be the best based on what WE say.
I know that I, as a Virtual World user, the things that make virtual worlds become so popular is....
I think that vSide has one of the best, but I don't mean so in game. Because vSide is still fairly small, a good percent of you all know each other or have met at least once. Which makes vSide kind of feel like a high school and not so much a big world because it's really not.
The creators control the environment, the avatars, and the actions. And of course the reason being is that vSide appeals to a certain age group unlike Second Life, so it has to be more controlled.
So what can vSide add to improve community while still retaining control?
I know some of these are being worked on or have been suggested, but I wanted to point out some of the important ones.
Community Side
Giving users ability of avatar creation (clothes, hair, make up, accesories, etc....) - This will also give users a way to earn vPoints as well as make a name for themselves w/in the community.(by selling some of the hottest clothing)
User2User games - Giving us something to do besides party. Card games, arcade games, Boat Races,
User2User interaction - I've suggested this before at office hours, like the kissing couch, but w/ out having there to be a couch there... Hugs, Kisses, Hi 5's, Cuddle, Piggy Back rides, Holding Hands, Slow dancing,
Voice Chat - Like there.com and VMTV. Mouth moving to the sound of your voice would be pretty cool.
Apartment Security - Password locked housing, shared access. (giving someone else the ability to move your stuff around)
Pictures, Music in Apts - I think this is being worked on, but it would be cool if we could play our own music from our vStereo.
User Interface
I actually really like the user interface right now. It's easy to understand and navigate.
vSide Developer Tool
Now... I know that IMVU and There has this... But a program like this would only be for the sole purpose of creating clothes and stuff for the avatars. As well as possibly being able to make our own hair styles, make up for our faces, etc... Imagine if this is implemented, that Salon idea someone suggested would really shine!
So this is just my... ELABORATE analysis of virtual worlds as a whole and vSide. You don't have to read this all if you don't want to, but if you happen to read it, let me know what you think.